Our Process
Mission First’s Customized Search Process
1. Discovery & Mission Alignment
We begin by deeply understanding your organization—its mission, values, culture, and team dynamics.
- One-on-one consultation with hiring managers
- In-depth review of the job description and ideal candidate profile
- Discussion of goals, budget, and timeline
- Alignment on diversity, equity, and inclusion priorities
Why it matters: We’re not just filling a role—we’re finding someone who believes in your cause.
2. Role Optimization
We help fine-tune the job description to attract top-tier, mission-aligned talent.
- Salary benchmarking & job market insights
- Clarity on must-haves vs. nice-to-haves
- Positioning the role to appeal to nonprofit professionals
3. Sourcing & Outreach
We cast a wide but targeted net using a variety of channels:
- Our curated talent pool of nonprofit professionals
- Outreach to passive candidates via LinkedIn and other platforms
- Partnerships with mission-driven job boards
- Community referrals and nonprofit network taps
4. Screening & Shortlisting
Every candidate is vetted not just for skills, but for mission fit.
- Behavioral and values-based interviews
- Skills assessments (if needed)
- Reference checks
- You receive a shortlist of highly qualified, purpose-aligned candidates
5. Interview Coordination & Support
We help make the interview process smooth for you and the candidates.
- Scheduling and communication
- Providing feedback to candidates
- Coaching hiring teams on how to assess for mission fit
6. Selection & Offer Support
We support you through the offer stage to ensure clarity and alignment.
- Offer consultation (compensation, benefits, expectations)
- Negotiation support
- Onboarding tips tailored for nonprofit teams
7. Post-Hire Follow-Up
We stay connected to ensure a smooth transition and long-term success.
- 30/60/90-day check-ins
- Candidate and client feedback
- Replacement guarantee (if applicable)
This process ensures you’re not just hiring a great candidate—you’re investing in someone who’ll move your mission forward.